Rob Newton – York’s Changemakers Local Evidence Lead (LEL) – outlines on-the-ground lessons from York as part of the Changemakers programme. Including why a holistic approach to evidence and data – as represented in the Foundations’ evidence pie – is crucial in putting in place effective evidence-based local services for children and families.
Good evidence does not change practice on its own. My experience as York’s Local Evidence Leader (LEL) with Changemakers has brought that home: while knowing what the research says is important, it is only the start. The core work is bringing people together to make sense of the broad range of evidence that exists to try to determine the most effective approaches to support children and families’ local needs and conditions.
With the Changemakers evaluation now published, I’ve been reflecting on what I’ve learned. A big part of the LEL role is building relationships, bringing people together and working through challenges; connecting strategy with the realities of delivery takes leadership, trust, and ongoing conversations.
To read the descriptive text for this graphic, please click here.
The experience has also strengthened my view that ‘what works’ evidence is only one slice of the evidence pie. Research findings matter, and so does local data, practitioner expertise, lived experience, and knowledge of the local context. My role is to help bring those perspectives together, rather than treat any one of them as the whole answer, which risks overlooking what is needed to make an approach work locally for children and families.
Another lesson is that implementation is important. Knowing that an approach or intervention can work is valuable and understanding how to make it work locally is just as important. In complex systems, the practical questions about delivery cannot be separated from the evidence about effectiveness.
That is why the Implementation Framework we have co-developed in York with Foundations, and tested in the other Changemakers local authorities, feels like an important next step. For me, it takes forward a central lesson from Changemakers: we need to pay as much attention to how evidence is put into practice as to what it tells us. It is a way of building on that learning and keeping the practical realities of implementation at the heart of the conversation.
Being an LEL means helping people make sense of evidence, and supporting them to use it to make better decisions in the commissioning, design, and delivery of local support for children and families. I hope the learning from Changemakers encourages a broader national conversation about evidence use – one that values the whole evidence pie – and in doing that, understands and works with the realities of delivering life-enhancing support for children and families in local authorities.
—
About Changemakers: Jointly funded by the Department for Education (DfE) and the Youth Endowment Fund (YEF), and part of the National Family Hubs programme, Changemakers aimed to bridge the gap between evidence and practice through embedding local evidence leadership in children’s services. The programme took place in Merton, Wirral, Stockport, and City of York, starting in April 2024 and ending in March 2026. The findings from the evaluation of Changemakers were published in October 2026.
Find out more about Changemakers on our website.